You Were Never Really Here (Lynne Ramsay, 2017)
Imdb
Date Watched: 11/01/19
Cinema or Home: Home
Reason For Watching: Joaquin Phoenix
Rewatch: Yes.
Decided to make today a Joaquin Phoenix/Mental Health double feature.
Both
Joker and
You Were Never Really Here are character studies of men who have endured unimaginable suffering and struggle with the effects of both physical and emotional trauma and who turn to violence to cope. Both are socially isolated men whose only real relationships are with their elderly mothers.
But despite these similarities, these are two very different men and two very different movies.
Joker's Arthur Fleck finds fulfillment in killing. It's therapy for him and is shown in graphic, shocking detail. It's in your face and he announces to the world why he does what he does.
But such is not the case with Joe, the subject of our study here.
You Were Never Really Here is a quiet meditation on the effects of trauma. Joe doesn't talk to anyone about his troubles. He isn't crying out for help like Arthur Fleck. He isn't looking for anyone to listen to or understand him. He barely even speaks a word. His torment is instead written on his face and expressed through his actions.
And that's what makes this film so unique and engrossing: It refuses to give in to expectations. It is completely without joy of any kind. We get a story about a man who doles out brutal justice to some of the world's monsters with the bash of a hammer, but neither Joe nor the audience is given any real satisfaction or fulfillment in the act. The violence occurs offscreen and we get to see only its bloody aftermath. Even when we are witness to the death of one of Joe's victims, the scene is turned into an unexpected moment of humanity and compassion. But even the most effective writing would be wasted without a compelling central performance and in this, of course, Joaquin Phoenix does not disappoint.
+