Talk to Me, 2022
Mia (Sophie Wilde) is in an emotionally challenging place: her mother has died under tragic circumstances, and she’s having a hard time dealing with her father, Max (Marcus Johnson). Mia spends most of her time hanging out with her best friend Jade (Alexendra Jensen), Jade’s brother Riley (Joe Bird), and Jade’s boyfriend, Daniel (Otis Dhanji), who just happens to be Mia’s former flame. Mia, Riley, Jade, and Daniel get mixed up in a disturbing part trend where teens grasp a hand sculpture and invite the spirits of the undead to enter their minds. While it’s all fun and chills at the beginning, when one of the parties goes very wrong, Mia must try to save herself and her friends.
Disturbing and empathetic to its teenage protagonists, this is a solid and solidly-upsetting horror film.
There are a lot of ways in which this film went in unexpected directions for me, but maybe my favorite is simply who it chooses to center. In 95% of other versions of this film, the main character would be Jade: she’s nice, polite, she breaks the rules a little bit. Pretty, sweet Jade with a boyfriend, and a little brother, and a best friend who is kind of a mess. And this is absolutely nothing against Jade. The character, and the way she’s played by Jensen, is very likable and relatable.
But instead we have Mia as our centered character, and between the way she is written and the way she is performed by Wilde, she walks a very fine line of being someone that you can root for, as her mistakes and selfish choices cause more and more damage to those around her. Mia is a mess, and it’s a testament to the film and Wilde’s performance that even as Mia makes choices that are infuriating or wrong, we can understand why she makes them. Mia is thrown some cruel curveballs, and as selfish, stupid, or just plain obnoxious as she can be, she’s clearly a person who is in pain and genuinely cares for her found family.
All of the characters, in fact, stay on exactly the right side of likability. Even the worst characters---Hayley (Zoe Terakes) and Joss (Chris Alosio), the teenage boys who own the mysterious hand---aren’t merely caricatures. One of the scariest things about watching this movie is just how believable the dynamics are between the teenagers. If you swap out the ghost-hand for a drug or some stupid game like giving yourself electrical shocks, this is teenage behavior through and through. The peer pressure. The pride in doing something bold in front of your friends. The setting boundaries to keep things “safe”, even though the whole thing is overtly unsafe. The false sense of security that builds every time things don’t go horribly wrong.
In the plot department, I also felt that there was a lot to like. This isn’t your typical movie about possession or about someone seeing strange things. I won’t go into any detail, but the complications that arise from the teens using the hand are complicated and layered, and test their limits personally and as a group. And the film is very wise to keep the exact nature of what is happening just the right amount of vague. Every time Mia makes a choice; every time something is communicated from the spirits; we sit right there next to the characters having to decide what is real, what is smart, and what it all means.
On the horror front, yeah, there’s some grisly and upsetting stuff here. (Warning to animal lovers that there is a scene toward the very beginning that is upsetting). There’s some pretty effective gore, and also an escalating sense of dread through the whole film. This is the kind of story where, no matter how you interpret it, it’s messed up stuff. Thankfully, while the film does put several characters through the wringer, it doesn’t have a sense of cruelty to it, or a sense that we are meant to root for any of the characters who get hurt along the way.
I didn’t have much to fault here. While I liked the ambiguity of most of the film, there was one plot point that was unexplained that bugged me a little, simply because it didn’t seem to follow the internal “rules” of what we’d seen so far. But that is a very minor quibble.
Solid and scary stuff.