Oklahoma, 1955
In this classic musical, Laurey (Shirley Jones) is wooed by the all-American Curly (Gordon MacRae) and by the creepy farmhand Jud (Rod Steiger). As the men compete for her affection and attention, other locals go through romantic quibbles, including the outgoing Ado Annie (Gloria Grahame).
This was a film that really exemplified the way that a movie can wow you on one front and totally underwhelm you on another.
On the positive side, the musical elements of the film are almost all spot on. The choreography is really fun and transitions between more "stage" numbers and pieces that incorporate more of the "real" surroundings. There is an extended sequence in the film that is a dream that Laurey has about the feud between Curly and Jud that really stunned me. The lighting, the dancing, and the other-worldliness of it was just super cool. I found the songs to be perfectly serviceable (no new favorites, but nothing that felt like a slog, either).
For the most part, I enjoyed the performances. Steiger's performance in particular is interesting for the genuine note of menace and danger that he injects into the proceedings. Most of the film feels like it follows "stage rules"--where punches and even guns don't mean all that much. But Steiger's Jud is like a dark cloud floating in the musical's otherwise blue sky. Increasingly, things that "don't" happen in this kind of musical--assault, sexual assault, murder--start to seem more possible than they have any right to. It's a weird dynamic, having a character who feels like he teleported in from some alternate universe, but I liked it.
On the downside, um, these people all were the worst and it was hard spending time with them when they weren't singing or dancing. Obviously I'm not saying that characters shouldn't have flaws, but yeesh. Everyone was dumb, manipulative, annoying, or some other trait that made it hard to want to root for them. My dislike for the characters was largely tempered by the actors' skills as singers and dancers and the excellent staging of many sequences, but it was challenging to go through so many minutes of a film in which I wasn't cheering anyone on.
I'd like to say that my favorite character was the unabashedly promiscuous Ado Annie, but despite enjoying the writing of the character the most, Grahame's performance was the only one I had really mixed feelings about. There was something . . . . uncomfortable about her portrayal of the character. As if she'd crossed a line between portraying someone who is ditzy and portraying someone who has active brain damage. I just could not handle some of the facial expressions, especially during her first number. I've never felt so uneasy watching a musical performance.
I'm really on the fence about how to rate this one, and I think I'm going with my lower inclination. While I appreciated the technical aspects of the film, the story itself and most of the characters really didn't do much for me. I will say that I think it's super cool that the cast and crew filmed this whole movie TWICE, because they were filming it in two different formats. It's a film that I can respect for many reasons, but you'd have to pay me to watch it again.