Thank you for all the replies. Based on the recommendations, I've bumped these movies to the top of my watchlist:
Pretty Woman (1990)
The Bodyguard (1992)
Four Weddings and a Funeral (1994)
Ever After: A Cinderella Story (1998)
Hope Floats (1998)
Blast from the Past (1999)
Pretty Woman also just sticks out as something you should definitely watch. I’m not the biggest fan, but I think it’s a head above most rom-coms. Surprised you haven’t seen it.
I'm surprised that I haven't seen a few of these too, especially
Pretty Woman and
Runaway Bride, because I like Richard Gere, but I've never been much of a fan of Julia Roberts for some reason.
The Bodyguard is in no way a RomCom, of course. Would not classify Practical Magic as a RomCom, either. Sliding Doors is more of a dramady. Hope Floats is a drama.
Of that list, Pretty Woman (1990) and Four Weddings & a Funeral (1994) are must-sees in my book, with My Best Friend's Wedding (1997) I'd slot just behind those two. Blast from the Past is very cute, Honeymoon in Vegas is pretty fun, Never Been Kissed is alright, One Fine Day is old fashioned but sweet enough.
My taste in RomComs is mostly different than your list (and not only because I cannot stand Adam Sandler). My favorites are...
Joe versus the Volcano (1990)
L.A. Story (1991)
Defending Your Life (1991)
Hear My Song (1991)
Groundhog Day (1993)
Barcelona (1994)
Muriel's Wedding (1994)
Speechless (1994)
French Kiss (1995)
While You Were Sleeping (1995)
The American President (1995)
As Good As It Gets (1997)
Grosse Pointe Blank (1997)
Addicted to Love (1997)
Rushmore (1998)
Notting Hill (1999)
Thanks for the info about several of these movies. I thought
The Bodyguard was supposed to be more of a romance/thriller, not a rom-com, but I've seen the trailer and it looks like it could be a good movie.
From your list,
While You Were Sleeping (1995) is a lock for my list, and
The American President (1995) and
Defending Your Life (1991) also could make my list.
I've seen
Groundhog Day (1993),
As Good As It Gets (1997), and
Notting Hill (1999), and I like them, but they're likely to just miss my list.
I've also seen
Joe versus the Volcano (1990),
L.A. Story (1991),
French Kiss (1995),
Grosse Pointe Blank (1997), and
Rushmore (1998), but it's been so long since I've seen them that I don't remember much about them. I'll have to rewatch them if I get a chance.
Did anyone mention Sleeping With The Enemy?
Back in the day, it was a popular movie. Not sure how I would feel about it now.
Dying Young was a good movie too.
Julia Roberts had a good run in the 90s.
I saw
Sleeping With The Enemy a long time ago, but if I remember correctly, I thought it was overrated at the time.
I haven't seen
Dying Young.