But I believe you made a typo, you must have meant to knock Hitch's
Rope. Now that movie is seriously flawed
If you think of it as a perfect murder story undermined by a lame MacGuffin, then, yes.
But I think it's about a one-upmanship between two incredibly narcissistic characters, Rupert and Brandon.
Smug Rupert who can't stop talking about his fancy-intellectual theories, and psychopath Brandon who wanted to show him his pièce de résistance and let his former teacher know that he could do better than just talking about it.
I think, at the very least, it's an interesting film to discuss.
Hitchcock was very good in the horror and romance genre (The Birds, Notorious) but the ones that are supposed to be more clever or sophisticated usually don't work for me.
There's always something that works against the nature of the story.
Why would Uncle Charilie suddenly drop his guard and talk about widows in the most vicious way? It sure took the shadow out of it.
Why is Bruno stalking Guy when the whole point was to be strangers ('on a train") - OK, I understand that doesn't actually work in movie, but the fact that Bruno (of all characters) was emotionally triggered by Miriam's glasses does not make any sense at all.
And still, all of that could be forgiven if they had been interesting characters to watch.
Bitchy slutty Miriam was fun, but she got killed in the first act.
North By Northwest is a cracker, of course.
Now what would you put forth as a favorite that we can all dump on? Are you willing to cite a favorite? I did.....your turn now.
Alright, I'm "coming out" as a fan of The Baby (1973).
Go on, laugh! Taunt me! Bring on the tar and feathers.