Well. That's interesting...how did this. -
turn into this-
?
Thank God for the editing tool.
In reply, however, sure I'm biased as hell, and I don't care if you think so. I give brief reasons as to why I love a film or why I hate it. If you disagree, write your own review. If I love a film, I'm not going to take special pains to dissect it and find flaw in it. I love it, and I don’t want to.
I don’t “just act like a fanboy writing his pants-wetting favorite parts of the film rather than breaking them down in a technical and rational manner.” I AM a fanboy etc, etc. I love film, and I love to enjoy film. To hell with being cynical and picking film apart. If that’s what you’re into, I’m down with it. Just don’t expect me to.
I can’t see how anyone can find Hellboy crappy. On a technical level, the sound is lovely, the editing is crisp and it’s beautiful to look at (much like all of Guillermo del Toro’s films thus far). It’s a wonderful, heartwarming film. But then again, that’s just my fanboy opinion. I love the film, and if you don’t, there’s no reason to further the conversation, because ya' aren’t going to change me' fanboy mind. *Thank God for Irish accents*
And, to clarify, I’m a fan of all genres. I didn’t like House of 1000 Corpses on any level. Genre or no genre. I thought it sucked. You, however, are perfectly entitled to think otherwise.
Maybe you’re right, though…I shouldn’t write reviews if it’s to be from a biased stance (which, if I love or hate a film, is the only stance I’m willing to take). In spite of the fact that the whole world is biased, I feel I shouldn’t pollute your opinions with mine. Henceforth, I resign from posting reviews.
Originally Posted by scitek
Hellboy was crap. House of 1000 Corpses wasn't nearly as bad as you make it out to be if you watch it as a fan of the genre. And congratulations on your biased as hell reviewing. First, you go into such great, concise detail about the movies that you like. You give them all the time of day. However, when you come to a movie you happen to dislike. All I read are things such as, "It has bad acting, and the story went something like, blah blah blah, oh well the point is it sucks, and this is proven fact and you should listen to me the almighty and powerful..."
I like a lot of the films that you have reviewed so far, but I don't think you're anywhere near fair when reviewing them. You just act like a fanboy writing his pants-wetting favorite parts of the film rather than breaking them down in a technical and rational manner. Give me REAL reasons to not watch or watch something rather than strict opinion. It IS possible to review something and analyze it in a manner where your opinion doesn't take over. Does it tell a complete story? Does it keep you interested? Is the editing too frantic or too slow? Was the casting done properly? All these questions should be answered, but then...that's just my opinion.
I like a lot of the films that you have reviewed so far, but I don't think you're anywhere near fair when reviewing them. You just act like a fanboy writing his pants-wetting favorite parts of the film rather than breaking them down in a technical and rational manner. Give me REAL reasons to not watch or watch something rather than strict opinion. It IS possible to review something and analyze it in a manner where your opinion doesn't take over. Does it tell a complete story? Does it keep you interested? Is the editing too frantic or too slow? Was the casting done properly? All these questions should be answered, but then...that's just my opinion.
Originally Posted by scitek
Nice job!
Thank God for the editing tool.
In reply, however, sure I'm biased as hell, and I don't care if you think so. I give brief reasons as to why I love a film or why I hate it. If you disagree, write your own review. If I love a film, I'm not going to take special pains to dissect it and find flaw in it. I love it, and I don’t want to.
I don’t “just act like a fanboy writing his pants-wetting favorite parts of the film rather than breaking them down in a technical and rational manner.” I AM a fanboy etc, etc. I love film, and I love to enjoy film. To hell with being cynical and picking film apart. If that’s what you’re into, I’m down with it. Just don’t expect me to.
I can’t see how anyone can find Hellboy crappy. On a technical level, the sound is lovely, the editing is crisp and it’s beautiful to look at (much like all of Guillermo del Toro’s films thus far). It’s a wonderful, heartwarming film. But then again, that’s just my fanboy opinion. I love the film, and if you don’t, there’s no reason to further the conversation, because ya' aren’t going to change me' fanboy mind. *Thank God for Irish accents*
And, to clarify, I’m a fan of all genres. I didn’t like House of 1000 Corpses on any level. Genre or no genre. I thought it sucked. You, however, are perfectly entitled to think otherwise.
Maybe you’re right, though…I shouldn’t write reviews if it’s to be from a biased stance (which, if I love or hate a film, is the only stance I’m willing to take). In spite of the fact that the whole world is biased, I feel I shouldn’t pollute your opinions with mine. Henceforth, I resign from posting reviews.
__________________
"I'm mad as hell, and I'm not going to take it anymore!" - Howard Beale
"I'm mad as hell, and I'm not going to take it anymore!" - Howard Beale
Last edited by Beale the Rippe; 04-11-04 at 09:48 PM.