Blithe Spirit, 1945
Charles and Ruth are hosting a fun evening with another couple. They hire a local medium to come and perform a seance at entertainment, but it all gets a little too real when the spirit of Charles' first wife, Elvira, is summoned and doesn't seem to be going anywhere. Visible only to Charles, her presence causes a rift between Charles and Ruth.
This movie could--and should!--have been great, but somehow I felt like it landed at "good."
On the positive side, the dialogue absolutely crackles with dry humor (courtesy mostly of Noel Coward's source material) and the actors deliver their lines very well. All of the relationships bristle with love-hate energy, and that's a fun dynamic when it comes to their conversations.
It would be wrong to not call out Margeret Rutherford's totally stellar performance as the medium. Equal parts kooky old lady and poltergeist fan-girl, Rutherford is utterly charming as a woman who is in over her head and ecstatic that she gets to be a part of a genuine paranormal experience.
The problem that I had with the film had a lot to do with character development and motivation. There seems to be very little genuine affection between Charles and Ruth or between Charles and Elvira. That could have been fine, because a marriage doesn't have to be loving to be funny. But none of them really make sense as a couple. More than that, the lack of affection means that the motivations of the characters seem muddled. Elvira doesn't really like Charles, and frequently says that she wants to go back to where she was. But then we're told that she's plotting his death so that he'll join her in the afterlife. I never felt like I got much of a grip on what any of the main characters actually wanted--out of life or from each other.
There's an aimlessness to the movie that work out okay in the middle because the dialogue is so good and the performances are so fun. But going into the final act the one-liners can't float the film any longer. I was actually somewhat confused by the last 15 minutes, and the lack of world-building and character building left me feeling like I didn't totally understand why certain things had happened and how the characters were meant to feel about them.
I did enjoy the way that the movie was filmed. It comes across (in a good way) as a mix between a film and a stage-play. I liked that Lean alternated between showing and not showing Elvira--making some clever uses of empty space to help us understand different perspectives.
I'd call this one a near-miss.