+1
1. T1 or T2---For its big budget nuclear winter scene and the tiniest of gestures, I'll give Terminator 2 the edge. Terminator is a pretty solid, lean, mean thriller though.
2. GF1 or GF2---I need to give Godfather 2 a rewatch. But Godfather is like a delectable cannoli at your favorite Italian restaurant.
3. Die Hard or With a Vengeance---I'm confident that Die Hard remains something that holds up well even with its missteps (Mr and Mr. Johnson). Vengeance is the best of the sequels, but a far cry from the original.
4. Alien or Aliens---It's like trying to determine which child is better looking. Let's go with Alien which has that one scene, for now. But tomorrow, it could be Aliens. It's that close.
5. Raging Bull or Rocky---Raging Bull is a well-done brutal boxing movie. Based loosely on a real life story, Rocky is a well-done feel good boxing movie. I'm going with Rocky.
6. Tatsuya Nakadai vs Toshirō Mifune---May have to abstain since I haven't seen anything Nakadai has done, but considering the amount of life Toshiro Mifune brought to The Seven Samurai, he's got his work cut out.
7. For a Few Dollars More vs A Fistful of Dollars---Fistful of Dollars for that interesting score and bringing in Lee Van Cleef. The film felt more fresh as well.
8. Ennio Morricone vs John Williams---John Williams had a good run from the mid 1970s to the late 1990s, but Ennio Morricone had been doing strong work until his death earlier this year.
9. Newman vs Redford---Robert Redford is a solid actor who can offer gravitas (Captain America: The Winter Soldier), charisma (Our Souls at Night) or goofiness (Barefoot in the Park). Yet, I think there's something about Paul Newman that just rises above.