Fallen Angel, 1945
Grifter Eric (Dana Andrews) is kicked off of a bus, landing in a small town where he immediately takes a liking to local wild woman Stella (Linda Darnell). But true to his ways, Eric's head is equally turned by a woman named June (Alice Faye) and maybe more specifically turned by the fortune that June is set to inherit. But June has a watchful sister named Clara (Anne Revere), and when a shocking crime rocks the town, everyone seems to be a suspect.
This is a pretty good little thriller/drama that really picks up steam in its final act and managed to keep me guessing up until the final cards were played.
My two favorite characters in this one were Stella and Clara, two very different women but so much more fully realized than the other characters that they really pop. Stella is the kind of character who, in a lesser film, would be treated with a lot of contempt. She has a reputation for sleeping around, and there are multiple men who are obsessed with her, from Eric to a guy named Pop (Percy Kilbride) who owns the diner where she works. Stella is in a position where she depends on male attention and affection, but at the same time has grown openly contemptuous of them. She isn't on screen for more than 5 minutes before telling one guy to his face "You make me sick," because of his fawning over her. Stella just seems to believe that Eric might be the person to help her out of the endless cycle, and that hope gives her a very human dimension.
Clara, who is very prim and proper, is in many ways a great foil for Stella. Clara was conned out of a great deal of her family's money by a man, and has been left with suspicion. She looks at Eric with the same weary eye as Stella, and it's personal experience that causes her agony as June continues forward with her romance with Eric. I guess I also liked Clara because it's hard to watch her endure her sister making such stupid decisions. I was a little sad that we didn't get to see more of her in the very last act.
When it comes to the central characters of Eric and June, I wasn't quite as engaged. June is just, well, ya girl dumb. Real dumb. The film does establish that June has led a pretty sheltered life, and that she has some resentment over having been controlled by her sister and basically punished for her sister's mistakes. That's all understandable. But there's a part where she's talking to Eric and just falls asleep on his shoulder. And then . . . stays asleep? Um, does June have a medical condition we don't know about? And the problem is partly that Andrews and Faye don't have enough sexual chemistry to believe that she'd marry him out of lust. Neither is Eric so charming that I buy that he wins her over to the total detriment of her common sense. Noir is full of people making bad choices, but I found June irritating right up to the last frame.
Thankfully, the film is chock full of suspects right up until the end. I loved how many people could have genuinely been guilty, and it makes for a very unpredictable finale. This saves the film from the lackluster and frustrating central relationship.