Wild Girl, 1932
In a rural California town, Salomy Jane (Joan Bennett) is a tomboy who restlessly resists the wooing of charming gambler Jack (Ralph Bellamy), the ineffectual Rufe (Irving Picher), and the handsy politician Baldwin (Morgan Wallace). But things take a turn one day when a stagecoach robbery takes place and a local is murdered, with suspicion of the murder falling on a newly arrived stranger (Charles Farrell). Salomy has reason to defend the stranger, slowly coming to realize she has feelings for him.
This movie is an everything bagel of comedy, drama, thriller, romance, and Western---and this bagel is, for the most part, delicious.
On the comedy front, the film delivers a series of ribald jokes with the same pattern of giving a meaningful pause before delivering a second half that renders the statement innocuous. “He was stripping women . . . of their jewels.” “When you find the right man you’ll get out of those pants . . . and into a dress.” The cast has a good old time delivering these lines, and their amusement is contagious.
The drama and thriller elements are also pretty effective. In a sequence that’s all the more shocking for following on a lot of silliness, Baldwin waits behind a tree near where Salomy is swimming nude in a lake, accosting her when she emerges. The attack leaves her with nasty bruises on her arm, something we see twice more during the film. Salomy hypothesizes that a later attack on Baldwin was probably motivated by the similar assault of another woman, something that proves prescient. The other drama subplot involves a local man who is suspected of committing the stagecoach robbery. The film spends a lot of time with the man, his wife, and their children, giving a lot of impact to what comes later in that plot.
The romance is also fun for the most part. For a while it cruises along in a “love at first sight” mode, but there’s a pretty good sequence in the middle where Salomy realizes that the stranger may have killed the man who tried to rape her, and is deeply disturbed by the idea that he might be executed for having done so. With the local authorities basically brushing off her report of being assaulted, all she can offer the stranger is affection and a pretty sexy kiss. There is something a bit disappointing about the fact that Salomy likes a guy and then all of a sudden goes around in modest dresses instead of her pants and shirt. Thankfully she’s still very feisty to the last frame. Farrell plays his part well, a job that requires being adorable, guileless, and rugged in turn.
A special mention has to go to Eugene Pallette, the local carriage driver who acts as almost a greek chorus to all of the action. He keeps each character up to date on the latest events, and gently intervenes at certain moments to help make things right and support the community.
The one aspect of the film that sticks out like a sore thumb is the treatment of its Black characters. While Louise Beavers is an engaging presence (and gives a great delivery of the “get you out of those pants” line), her character is the stereotypical Mammy. (And, yes, that’s her character’s name). The portrayal of the Black characters is positive, technically, but “positive” in the sense that they are enslaved people who are just as happy as can be. Just a whole lot of laughing and singing and hanging out--yup, the life of an enslaved person in the 1800s! It’s not a huge part of the run time, but these scenes occur enough to leave a lingering negative vibe.
Overall this one packs enough laughs and moments of genuine heart to be worth a watch, with a note that the racial politics are unfortunate.