Varan, 1958
Two scientists venture into a remote region of Japan to study rare butterflies, but are killed by a strange earthquake. Yuriko (Ayumi Sonoda) is a reporter and also the sister of one of the scientists, and she goes to investigate what really happened, along with scientist Kenji (Kozo Nomura). Disregarding the warnings from locals, the group goes into the mountainside and discovers a prehistoric creature called Varan. The military must scramble to contain and defeat the monster.
A cool monster design and likable protagonists can’t lift this above feeling like Godzilla-lite.
I’ll start by saying that the Criterion Channel lists this as
Varan the Unbelievable, but I believe that the version I watched is just
Varan, the original Honda film and not the Americanized film that poached footage.
While I’m glad I didn’t watch the (apparently unwatchable) remixed version, this original film is something of a let-down. The problem isn’t just that it borrows its overall structure from
Godzilla, but that it doesn’t deliver on the elements that made that film so great.
The first third of this one was very promising. The mysterious earthquake is a great inciting moment, introducing the very likable Yuriko and Kenji and adding personal stakes to the film. Then you get the reclusive village that worships a strange mountain god. A sequence where a young boy chases a runaway dog into the forest is a strong bit of suspense.
I will also never tire of the slow motion, roiling water slowly parting to reveal a monster, in this case the lizard-like Varan. I quite like the design of the creature, with spikes down its back and a more hunched posture.
But once the film hits that point of “oh, it’s a monster, how do we kill it?”, things get a bit bland. Like Godzilla before him, Varan emerges because of human activity damaging the environment, but there’s not the same sense of scientists weighing or reflecting on the impact that the military and industry are having on the natural world. Likewise, the sequences of destruction feel lifted from the earlier film, but don’t do anything different enough to distinguish themselves.
This was enjoyable enough to watch, but not distinct enough to make a real lasting impression.