Penguins of Madagascar.
Directors: Eric Darnell, Simon J. Smith
Writers: Micheal Colton, John Aboud, Brandon Sawyer, Alan Schoolcraft, Brent Simons, Eric Darnell, Tom McGrath
Voice cast: Tom McGrath, Chris Miller, Christopher Knights, Conrad Vernon, Benedict Cumberbatch, John Malkovitch.
Penguins of Madagascar is a spin off the film series Madagascar, which I'm sure majorly confused anyone going into this blind, as Madagascar is only referenced briefly in what amounts to an in-joke. The general consensus was that the penguins were the best part of the movies, and after nine years, and their own shorts and TV series, Dreamworks just completely shined the spotlight on them with a full blown movie. It...didn't work out for them, financially (if you smell desperation coming from Dreamworks in the near future, you can blame this movie). But quality wise? Well...
The movie actually has a lot going for it. It has a lot of good jokes throughout; there's not much that'll get really big, "Doubled over, out of breath" type laughter, but good laughs nonetheless (unfortunately still some toilet humor. About three counts of it). Comedy's always been the penguins' main draw, and they don't disappoint there. It's Dreamworks, so the animation's good, both in settings and characters (the villain's an octopus that has a human disguise. It's hard to watch him and not imagine animators either having a field day or pulling their hair out). Action scenes were really fun to watch. They're fast paced and varied, and also manage to be fairly unique, taking advantage of the animation medium and wacky premise that's already suspended everyone's belief to allow for some ridiculous but still fun to watch scenes you wouldn't do in live action, (or if there's another movie where the characters move between airplanes while in midair or take a gondola on land, I'd like to see it). It surprisingly managed to hit the mark and make an emotional scene work, though only one of them out of multiple attempts.
Unfortunately, the story is where the whole thing slips and bangs its head. What's wrong with it? Well it's...weird. Very weird. And that probably seems like an odd complaint for an animated movie. After all, this is the medium with things like cooking rats and kung fu pandas, and this specific movie itself is about spy penguins. You go into this actively looking for weirdness, right? Yeah, but this is a whole new level of weird, past animals doing things they shouldn't do. Just to give you a taste, a character grows a hand out of their backside. And it actually becomes important later. And I've went and checked multiple websites just to make sure that actually happened because despite seeing the film I have a hard time believing it.
Obviously, weirdness can be a good thing. It is a comedy, after all, and indeed, there are a few moments where weirdness makes everything funnier. Even action scenes can benefit from a little weirdness. But the problem is that the weird stuff doesn't slow down or go away when a dramatic moment comes up. In fact, if anything, the weirdness just amps up during attempted emotional moments (second, more slightly spoilery taste of insanity; a main penguin gets kidnapped while wearing a mermaid costume). While I'm sure it's possible to blend emotional moments and over the top weirdness, whoever was handling these scenes is not at that level of film making. The two really don't mix well, and the end result is spending chunks of the movie (especially the climax. In fact, mostly the climax) stuck in this uncomfortable middle, wondering exactly what you're supposed to be feeling. And then you then end the movie with that being your final impression.
When it's not being weird, there's a bad guy who's jealous of the good guys, the good guys have to deal with the idea they aren't as good as they thought they were, and the youngest penguin wants to prove himself. Yeah, you've seen it before. Probably multiple times. Would the movie have benefited from some more originality? Definitely. But as is, it's a basic structure they can pile jokes and action on, and as that, it works. And if nothing else, the movie at least pulls off the plot elements decently. Well, most of them.
The movie's way of making the heroes question their abilities is to create four entirely new characters and an entirely new organization just to do the job a little self assessment could have (they already use a failure on their part to make them doubt themselves, the new guys just kind of point it out). The four characters, collectively part of an organization called "The North Wind", are not very interesting in and of themselves; neither their personalities nor their organization are given much fleshing out, and only one of them gets any development. When it all comes down to it, their job is to eat up screen time and to add a well known name to the marquee (Benedict Cumberbatch's name, specifically. The guy who can't say "penguins" correctly. I'm not sure if it's a brilliant or stupid casting choice). And the screen time they take is not screen time the movie had to spare; two of the penguins don't get plots or development of their own because the movie's busy with the North Wind. There's been some theorizing Dreamworks was hoping to spin them off for their own movie, and it sounds plausible. So at least this movie's failure prevented that from happening.
Overall, with a few changes, this could have been a much better movie. It apparently finished ahead of schedule, and shouldn't have been released until very recently, and I think keeping the original date and spending a few months tweaking it could have done wonders. As is, it's not bad. Good for comedy, good for animation, good for action, not so good for story but it's not outright horrible. It's not for people who want a groundbreaking emotional roller coaster, but it's a fun popcorn movie nonetheless. It probably didn't deserve to bomb like it did, but I can understand being hesitant to tell people "Yeah, that movie was good, go see it!" and subsequently bringing "What the hell did you just send me to!?" phone calls down on yourself.
Last edited by Colors; 04-19-15 at 03:16 PM.