The Breaking Point - 1950
Directed by Michael Curtiz
Written by Ranald MacDougall
Based on the novel "To Have and Have Not" by Ernest Hemingway
Featuring John Garfield, Patricia Neal, Phyllis Thaxter & Juano Hernandez
There's a real scrape in
The Breaking Point that has protagonist Harry Morgan (John Garfield) hang on to his livelihood, home, family and peace of mind by the barest free edges of his fingernails - constantly juggling to keep going another day, or even another few hours. This film noir classic has it's dingy, shadowy focus on a working man. A fishing boat captain who takes sporting fishers out for a certain amount of money, and barely makes a cent after paying the various fees, fines and costs that keep his business operating. Ernest Hemingway's novel, "To Have and Have Not", had kind of been adapted to the screen in the Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall 1944 film of the same name, directed by Howard Hawks - but that film differed wildly from the novel. That's the reason why this film came along after so little time - the story in the novel was really being told for the first time here. It's a really dark, rough and rugged film that throws little counter-balance out apart from the loving exchanges Harry has with wife Lucy (Phyllis Thaxter) and his kids.
Harry starts the film having to spend most of the advance money he gets on either fuel for his boat, or food for the family, and that's before his next customer stiffs him - meaning he lacks the cash to exit the port he's in. Shady lawyer F.R. Duncan (Wallace Ford) can offer one possible solution - transporting illegal immigrants into the United States for money. Something that could land Harry in jail for years. In the meantime, he's also tempted by seductress Leona Charles (Patricia Neal) - during which he proves beyond a shadow of a doubt the love he has for his family, his wife and his sense of self-pride and determination. Harry ends up trying to smuggle the Chinese immigrants in from Mexico, but the whole operation turns into a disaster and in the end brings down more heat from the authorities, who impound Harry's boat for a search and investigation. One more criminal enterprise could put Harry well ahead still - but results in tragedy for his partner Wesley Park (Juano Hernández) and might take Harry well beyond the breaking point.
I enjoy the incredible fun cinematographers have playing with shadow and darkness in film noir, but I don't think I've seen darkness used to such a strong effect as it is here. Director of photography Ted D. McCord (
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre,
Young Man With a Horn,
East of Eden and
The Sound of Music) drowns his characters in inky black nothingness, and has them fight blizzards of sharply delineated dark lines, crevasses of space where no light can enter and many phases of muted grey mystery. Often you'll just see a silhouette, and often when a character enters a shady joint the lights are down unbelievably low - as if patrons don't want to see what they're drinking. Harry's costume is dark, meaning at night we often can only see his face clearly. There are plenty of scenes outside during the day to provide much needed contrast and balance throughout the film. I enjoyed the noir cinematography of McCord, and the way he keeps us feeling claustrophobic on those boat trips, ironically out in a great expanse of water.
The other most notable aspect of the film aside from the story and cinematography is the performance of John Garfield, who is especially strong here - doing what he considered some of the best acting of his entire career. Garfield would come under pressure from various fronts not long after featuring in
The Breaking Point - family-wise, he'd lost a daughter five years previously and was at the time constantly cheating on his wife Roberta Seidman. It was the investigation by the FBI however, after his testimony to the House Committee on Un-American Activities, that would provide the most stress. Only two years after hitting a high point here, he found himself blacklisted and unable to get film work. Unable to sleep and constantly exerting himself, with his career in doubt and investigations ongoing, Garfield died of a heart attack on May 21, 1952. He was only 39-years-old. Here he shows what kind of promise the rest of his career showed in his second-last screen performance.
I found
The Breaking Point a very heavy, moving experience. I mean, the final scene and the way those final shots play out - with Wesley Park's son on the wharf looking for his father - are so solemn and bleak. The whole struggle-street saga is familiar enough, and it's a scene I don't have the fortitude to fight my way through. Lucy is always begging Harry to start a new career, but his determination and grit will see the man fight to the bitter end. There's a requisite cynicism to film noir that demands the ending we get - but it's tempered and not the worst of all endings possible. In the meantime the constant blows are felt by an audience totally on Harry's side, and pulling for him. Of course criminal enterprises are going to go wrong. When you deal with crooks you can't expect to be dealt with in a fair and square manner. Harry has a great head on his shoulders in a crisis though, and a lesser man would have ended up in a worse position. That's not saying, however, that his decisions were the right ones.
So, overall, even though
The Breaking Point didn't win any awards, it's reputation today is stellar, and there are plenty of people who give it the highest praise. Before now, I'd never heard of it and can't say I'm familiar with many of the actors who appear in it (Patricia Neal we'd see in
The Day the Earth Stood Still and
Hud later in her career.) It reminded me just a little of
Thieves Highway, and I can't help wonder if it's bitter tone regarding capitalism had anything to do with the left-leaning Garfield signing on to play the lead. The scenes featuring danger and action were some of the most thrilling, tense and gripping I've ever seen in a noir film - real edge-of-your-seat stuff and actually the greatest thing about the film while I'm in 'watching it' mode. Really, really exciting stuff, and props to editor Alan Crosland Jr. and Curtiz for crafting those moments that make this noir thriller go off with a bang. The breaking point indeed. We're often just a moment away, giving us those treasured movie moments where nothing else in the world exists.