You're over-thinking it. It's a movie adaptation of material that has been commenting on itself for several decades now, so in that sense it isn't anything new. It does a few things that the source material couldn't really do as well: it works extremely well as a bromance, it's as close to a full-blown musical as any comic book movie has ever been; and it is also an eulogy for a movie series produced by a now-defunct studio (and in some very subversive ways, it is also very critical of the media conglomerate that owns it).
But more than all of that, it's obviously the product of a creative team working on all cylinders and very much aware of the material's inherent flaws. It is, in its own viciously self-deprecating way, damn near perfect.
Yeah, I probably
am over-thinking it. And I'm probably just overdosing on the post-modern and the self-referential at this point. I remember back when I saw
Argylle and
The Fall Guy earlier this year, and I remember feeling frustrated and wondering why anything
can't just be a straight-ahead story anymore without commenting on itself. Which
isn't true, there are probably lots of movies that are more straightforward these days. But to me, it just
feels like there's a plethora of the post-modern these days, and it's kind of wearing thin on me. (And yet somehow, I
am a fan of the recent
Inside Out 2, which is a commentary on human emotional states
by human emotional states. Post-modernism with its inner working components disguised, you might say.)
But it also kind of annoys me that something relatively straightforward yet ambitious like Kevin Costner's
Horizon series can't get arrested these days, while it looks like
Deadpool & Wolverine is going to clean up. (Frankly, it
almost makes one sympathize with Martin Scorsese's criticisms of the comic-book movie phenomenon, although I'm not in full accord with them.) Yes, we can argue about the merits of Costner's
Horizon back and forth
ad nauseum until the cows come home, but I can't help but feel like most moviegoers these days don't seem to trust anything unless it's something which makes them feel smarter and more clever or hip than they really are. Traditional narrative may as well be dead. Most of the time I feel like I'm the furthest thing from a cultural conservative as it's possible for
anyone to be, but at age 51, "hip" and "clever" is starting to wear a little thin with me. (That's probably one of the reasons why I'm starting to "age into" an appreciation of Westerns these days.)
BTW,
FilmBuff, if criticism of media conglomerates as "on the nose" as it is in
Deadpool & Wolverine is even
allowed by those conglomerates, I'd hardly call it "subversive."