Negotiations And Love Songs 1971-1986 is a nice place to start. It's got at least 14 of the songs I listed plus a couple of more, Diamonds on the Soles of Her Feet (a good one) and Slip Slidin' Away (a great song, which for some crazy reason I forgot to mention).
Paul Simon favorites (so far):
  • Late in the Evening
  • The Boy In The Bubble
  • Graceland
  • Slip Slidin' Away
  • Diamonds on the Soles of Her Feet
  • I Know What I Know
  • Mrs. Robinson
  • You Can Call Me Al