The MoFo Top 100 Musicals Countdown
→ in Movie Reviews
67
George Cukor, 1954
Judy Garland, James Mason, Jack Carson, Charles Bickford
7lists61points
A Star Is Born
Director
George Cukor, 1954
Starring
Judy Garland, James Mason, Jack Carson, Charles Bickford
I did not vote for Moana, but I certainly considered it. The songs are great and I found I appreciated them more with repeat viewings/listening.
A Star is Born is a film I watched as part of preparation for this countdown and I thought it was very good. Judy Garland is really great.
A Star is Born is a film I watched as part of preparation for this countdown and I thought it was very good. Judy Garland is really great.
X
Favorite Movies
I have only seen the Judy Garland version of A Star is Born and it is amazing. James Mason also makes that film and is genuinely believable as the washed up alcoholic and I think it's one of film's all time great performances. Also very few directors can do interplay and drama between strong willed and conflicted characters as well as George Cukor, who along with William Wyler might be one of the least appreciated great filmmakers who is not a "household" name among the likes of a John Ford, Orson Welles, or Alfred Hitchcock. I've heard stories that Cukor had a reputation as a "woman's director," and I believe he directed parts of Gone With the Wind too and had some run ins with Clark Gable, if memory holds. But A Star is Born is great and Garland and Mason play so well of each other that I can't imagine any other version of the story being anything but a lesser rendition of the gold standard.
For those reasons, A Star is Born, made my list at number 19.
So far... unless I forgot or missed one, my picks that made the countdown:
19. A Star is Born
21. Easter Parade
22. 42nd Street
25. The Smiling Lieutenant
For those reasons, A Star is Born, made my list at number 19.
So far... unless I forgot or missed one, my picks that made the countdown:
19. A Star is Born
21. Easter Parade
22. 42nd Street
25. The Smiling Lieutenant
__________________
"A candy colored clown!"
Member since Fall 2002
Top 100 Films, clicky below
http://www.movieforums.com/community...ad.php?t=26201
"A candy colored clown!"
Member since Fall 2002
Top 100 Films, clicky below
http://www.movieforums.com/community...ad.php?t=26201
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Epic tale with a good balance of Drama, Mystery, Adventure, Comedy, song, dance and breathtaking animation. Moana was my #17.
A Star Is Born is super classic, expected it to place a bit higher. Haven't seen it since I was a kid though so no vote.
SEEN 13/34
BALLOT 3/25
25. Anastasia (1997)
19. Purple Rain (1984)
17. Moana (2016)
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Don't really consider O Brother Where Art Thou a musical. Love the movie though.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Seen 15/34. Maybe 16. Can't remember if I ever saw O Brother in its entirety.
7. The Smiling Lieutenant (1931) - #96
8. Into the Woods (2014) - #86
12. West Side Story (2021) - #90
16. Rocketman (2019) - #91
20. Funny Girl (1968) - #77
22. A Star Is Born (1954) - #67
25. Commentary! The Musical (2008) - One-pointer
I would've rather voted for the original A Star Is Born but there was some issue about "not having any songs in it."
7. The Smiling Lieutenant (1931) - #96
8. Into the Woods (2014) - #86
12. West Side Story (2021) - #90
16. Rocketman (2019) - #91
20. Funny Girl (1968) - #77
22. A Star Is Born (1954) - #67
25. Commentary! The Musical (2008) - One-pointer
I would've rather voted for the original A Star Is Born but there was some issue about "not having any songs in it."
X
User Lists
Moana was my 12! It's the best post 2000s Disney flick for me.
I'm shocked that A Star is Born didn't crack the top 50 although I have not seen it.
I'm shocked that A Star is Born didn't crack the top 50 although I have not seen it.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I go back and forth on Moana. Sometimes I like it and sometimes I don't, but I've never loved it. If I had stuck with my original intention of not doing any preparation for this countdown, I probably would've voted for it. But I did prepare and it eventually got cut.
I don't think I've seen A Star is Born and I don't particularly want to see it.
I don't think I've seen A Star is Born and I don't particularly want to see it.
__________________
Last edited by Miss Vicky; 1 week ago at 11:11 PM.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Moana is fine and has some really good scenes and songs, but overall I’m not a fan. There’s a lot I don’t like about it and it feels quite uneven and tonally weird and wobbly structured.
I have seen A Star is Born although not that version… if it’s anything like the newest version I don’t really see it as a musical so even if I saw and liked this I wouldn’t vote for it.
I have seen A Star is Born although not that version… if it’s anything like the newest version I don’t really see it as a musical so even if I saw and liked this I wouldn’t vote for it.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I voted for A Star is Born, and I must like the story because I threw other votes at it, including the 1937 version which I forgot wasn't a musical and therefore didn't count.
I don't believe I've seen Moana although it looks familiar.
5. Charlotte's Web (#79)
17. Calamity Jane (#84)
21. A Star is Born 1954 (#67)
25. 42nd Street (#76)
I don't believe I've seen Moana although it looks familiar.
5. Charlotte's Web (#79)
17. Calamity Jane (#84)
21. A Star is Born 1954 (#67)
25. 42nd Street (#76)
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I have seen A Star is Born although not that version… if it’s anything like the newest version I don’t really see it as a musical so even if I saw and liked this I wouldn’t vote for it.
The 1954 has the most musical genre vibe. The lead character is an actress that stars in musicals so you get actual "numbers".
X
User Lists
A Star is Born (1954) was #22 on my ballot. I guess I didn't right anything about it, but I was impressed with it.
Moana, I don't care about Disney or their movies, so no votes.
Moana, I don't care about Disney or their movies, so no votes.
X
Favorite Movies
Moana, I don't care about Disney or their movies, so no votes.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I have one Disney movie on my ballot (and Miss Vicky gave a legitimate Disney movie that I would have probably put on my list if it had crossed my mind), but outside of those two films and some vague childhood nostalgia for The Black Cauldron (never revisited as an adult and for this countdown. not a musical), I don't recall having any interest in Disney animated films. Partly due to the era I grew up, I guess.
Never have had much desire to see any version of A Star is Born.
Never have had much desire to see any version of A Star is Born.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Never have had much desire to see any version of A Star is Born.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
Moana was my #13. I love the film, not only because of the musical numbers, but they do factor into that highly. From the beautiful tunes of "How Far I'll Go" or the earworm of "You're Welcome" to the funky catchiness of "Shiny" or the more Polynesian flavor from the tunes written by Opetaia Foa'i (who I already knew because I was a fan of his band, Te Vaka, before this came up), it's all banger after banger. I know Frozen's "Let It Go" is the one that really hit big, but as far as I'm concerned, this is the soundtrack I just can't let go.
I haven't seen any version of A Star Is Born, but I've heard this one is probably the best or second best.
SEEN: 7/34
MY BALLOT: 2/25
I haven't seen any version of A Star Is Born, but I've heard this one is probably the best or second best.
SEEN: 7/34
MY BALLOT: 2/25
My ballot
__________________
Check out my podcast: The Movie Loot!
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I know "You're Welcome" will probably get the most thumbs up, but this is the one that always sticks with me the most.
As usual, Jermaine Clement is killing it.
As usual, Jermaine Clement is killing it.
X
Favorite Movies
X
User Lists
I saw Moana in the theater one snowy day when I arrived for massage school only to find that they'd done a half-day delay. It was such a pleasant surprise. I think that the songs are all really strong, as are the vocal performances. I like the look of it. All around just a really solid film.
Two things about Seven Brides for Seven Brothers:
1) The man who directed it had five wives! FIVE!
2) I had literally just finished a unit with my students about slavery. In the middle of class, some high schoolers come in and ask if they can talk to the class about the musical they're putting on. They describe the plot of the play. EVERY CHILD TURNS AND LOOKS AT ME. One student raises her hand and goes, "BUT---" and I was like "Thank you so much for coming to share, I'm sure there could be some interesting discussions about that play".
Anyway, I support your decision to avoid. It's a fantasy about a group of men kidnapping women because they read a myth literally about rape and thought "That's a good idea!". The dancing/production is great. I hated every character and the whole concept. It was played all the time on TV when I was a kid. A few years ago I decided to give it a fair shake and watch it beginning to end and it just confirmed the poor impression it had made all the times I caught it on TV.
After another MoFo described Seven Brides for Seven Brothers as "Seven Victims for Seven Rapists," I decided to make that one a hard pass.
1) The man who directed it had five wives! FIVE!
2) I had literally just finished a unit with my students about slavery. In the middle of class, some high schoolers come in and ask if they can talk to the class about the musical they're putting on. They describe the plot of the play. EVERY CHILD TURNS AND LOOKS AT ME. One student raises her hand and goes, "BUT---" and I was like "Thank you so much for coming to share, I'm sure there could be some interesting discussions about that play".
Anyway, I support your decision to avoid. It's a fantasy about a group of men kidnapping women because they read a myth literally about rape and thought "That's a good idea!". The dancing/production is great. I hated every character and the whole concept. It was played all the time on TV when I was a kid. A few years ago I decided to give it a fair shake and watch it beginning to end and it just confirmed the poor impression it had made all the times I caught it on TV.
X
Favorite Movies
X