Forbidden Planet remake

Tools    





File this one under "did we really need a remake of _____?", but it's happening anyway so let's hope it's good.



Warner Bros has made a deal to mount a new version of the 1956 science fiction classic Forbidden Planet. The film will be written by comic book and screenwriter Brian K. Vaughan, and it will be produced by Emma Watts.

For its forward-thinking themes, the film is considered a north star for science fiction writing and cinema that came after it. It has never had a big-screen remake — though James Cameron reportedly once considered it — partly because the rights were complicated and difficult to untangle. The studio and Watts finally got that major obstacle out of the way. The former studio chief Watts has leaned into producing the big ambitious tentpoles she shepherded from the executive suites, and this has the makings to be one of those.

Loosely based on Shakepeare’s The Tempest, Forbidden Planet is set in the 23rd century, where the starship C-57D arrives at the distant planet Altair IV to solve the mystery of what happened to another starship sent 20 years prior. One of that original ship’s scientists, Dr. Edward Morbius (played by Walter Pidgeon), warns them not to land for safety reasons, but C-57D does so anyway.

Their rescue attempts are hampered by a creature that begins killing members of the crew. The ship’s commander John J. Adams (Leslie Nielsen, back when he exclusively did serious roles) unravels a mystery that involves a relic from a long perished race that heightens intellect and does much worse. The film also starred Anne Francis as the daughter of Morbius; a major character in the film is Robby the Robot, the first in a sci-fi film that didn’t come off like a cheap tin can, and began the trek of AI-fueled robots that became staples of major sci-fi films to follow.

Vaughan is the Hugo- and Eisner Award-winning comic book writer and screenwriter whose comic creations include Y: The Last Man, Ex Machina, Runaways, Pride of Baghdad, Saga and Paper Girls. He also wrote on such comics as X-Men, Spider-Man and Captain America — and his TV work includes serving as writer, story editor and producer of three seasons of Lost, after being tapped by Damon Lindelof. Vaughan was then handpicked by Steven Spielberg to adapt Stephen King’s novel Under the Dome. He has the sci-fi bona fides.



File this one under "did we really need a remake of _____?", but it's happening anyway so let's hope it's good.


Before remaking it, I think they should just have John Williams compose a symphonic score for the original and air it in theaters. I think it would be a whole new experience with appropriate background & theme music.

Seriously, the Moog sound effects get to me after a while.



OMG It sounds awful. I hear the word revisionist and I just assume it will be the most ham-fisted nonsense that no one asked for.



About the last thing to make a remake of.
What it had going for it was the sets and the costumes and some of the special effects were groundbreaking.



I don't actually wear pants.
Why do the people in the picture look like students on their first day of their second year in film school...?
__________________
I destroyed the dastardly dairy dame! I made mad milk maid mulch!
Hey, babe, what game ya playing? Wanna smell my hair?



Ghouls, vampires, werewolves... let's party.
I love Forbidden Planet. I wish these morons in Hollywood would stop remaking old sci-fi classics. They had remade The Day the Earth Stood Still and it was horrible.



Trouble with a capital "T"
I understand the hesitation; I thought the remake of The Time Machine (1960) was horrible.
But sometimes remakes are better than the originals.
The remake was meh. I had even forgot they remade The Time Machine until just now.



This thread frankly shouldn't have been made until they actually start filming. Brian K Vaughn is a truly great writer but the adaptations of his work have just been completely underwhelming. Forbidden Planet should get a remake not as a film but rather as a Fargo-esque mini-series about different planets and how a crew deals with said events on said planet.



I was just saying that as a quip but if they actually did try and remake Plan 9 and take themselves seriously itd be hysterical Only if they took themselves seriously though. Otherwise it would be like Corey Felman trying ro act ridiculous, it would just fall flat



The Guy Who Sees Movies
This definitely goes into my "we will see" drawer. The Forbidden Planet is one of my all time favorite sci-fi-monster movies. I saw it as a kid in a drive-in in Minneapolis and, for about a week, I was sure that the Id Monster was outside my window. It's a period piece and a a masterpiece of what could be done with scenery and FX in its day. It's a reasonably smart plot line.

Even now, I love how the Id Monster was invisible until it was illuminated by ray guns. That, and its roar, were what scared the living sh*t out me as a kid. I can't help but wonder whether a remake would stay with the idea of an invisible energy monster.

This is like remaking Nosferatu, which I've seen twice with live chamber music accompaniment. That's been done too, but the talkie remake, decent as it was, is way behind the silent original, which is just so otherworldly.

The Forbidden Planet, with better FX would miss the point. Also, the original featured those early electronic music sound FX and background. That was terrific too.

Please don't do it.



Definitely love the use of Theremin in the original!



The Guy Who Sees Movies
It's gonna be real hard to beat the theremin sound and animation in the Great Machine sequence. Note how the film makers give you a sense of scale by having that little light in the upper right illuminate the humans so you know just how GD huge this thing it. Few sci-fi moments (or 4 minutes) have ever been better than this.




It can be redone. Does it need to be redone? What are the needs of our present moment? What purpose will it serve a today's audience?

If the themes are timeless, how will this film reindividuate these themes? A direct remake would be an attempt at an individuation that was appropriate to 1956 (e.g., flying saucers, spacey synths, traditional masculinity/femininity).

Apart from Cameron drawing an "S" at the end of Alien and drawing a vertical line through the "S," I don't know what the justification is. Will it make money merely because it is classic remake? Will people born in 2002 even care? Or is the idea that this is a great joke that they haven't heard yet, so we can retell it and recapture the magic? This seems to have been the idea behind the shot-for-shot remake of Psycho, but I don't recall that turning out so well...



The Guy Who Sees Movies
The one that scared the crap out of 5 year old me at the drive-in. The sequence is slow and insidious, and the electronic music sounds raise the ominous feeling of the invisible monster's approach. When the monster arrives (about 3 minutes in), the roar of the monster and screams of the crew are really creepy. Good sound on your computer is important here.