Young Sherlock Holmes -
Despite not being successful enough to kick off a franchise like Spielberg and company had hoped, Sherlock Holmes amateurs and experts will surely enjoy this mid-'80s family adventure. In case you ever wondered why Chris Columbus, the screenwriter, was likely selected to kick off what ended up being a very successful franchise - you know, that one about another British young man with special abilities - your explanation is here. The man knows how to craft a story featuring young folks, particularly ones compelled to defy authority figures, that is never not fun. I like Rowe as Holmes, especially for how he manages to balance the character's smugness about being the smartest and most observant person in any room with being someone you can believe as a devoted friend, i.e. to Watson. As for him, I was afraid his messiness and craving for sweets meant he would be reduced to a bumbling sidekick, but thankfully, Alan Cox, Columbus, et al give him more dimensions than that. Ultimately, they utilize such traits to humanize Watson rather than for mining cheap comic relief. Speaking of, I approve of how the hooded villain's weapon of choice, a blow dart tipped with a hallucinogenic poison, reveals our leads' hangups, fears, imperfections, what have you as well as how their mission to unmask the villain lets the heroes overcome them at the same time. The resulting special effects are also impressive, clever and in no way dated. I certainly will not reveal fine details of their assignment, but I'll at least say that it will surely please anyone who enjoys stories that go down the rabbit hole. I'll also add that fans of steampunk or the look and feel of Victorian England will surely get something out of it as well.
I had a fun time with this movie - the best compliment I can think to give it is I wish I had watched it in my youth - but I still consider it good, but not great. While the action to detective work ratio is more balanced here than it is in Guy Ritchie's middling 2009 movie, there is a still a bit too much of the former and not enough of the latter for my liking. Holmes' voiceover narration is also intrusive, so much so that it made me wonder if it is unnecessary. Other than that, it remains reliable and solid family entertainment, especially for the fall and winter seasons. It also works well as "spot the British character performer" entertainment since a good number of favorites show up here. Just make sure to do what every franchise and would-be franchise movie expects you to do lately: stick around after the end credits.