Manchester By The Sea
Kenneth Lonergan
It seems that every Oscar worthy performance has that one memorable "go for broke" scene. That scene is usually played at the Oscars as the desired "clip". Mark Ruffalo's performance comes to mind from last year's Spotlight. A decent performance until he explodes with emotional rage in one particular scene. Why bring this up? Well, Manchester By The Sea doesn't have any of those scenes. Casey Affleck doesn't go for broke and deliver an emotional powerhouse scene. Instead he grounds his performance in realism. Here is a guy who is clinically depressed for the rest of his life and Affleck plays it subdued and realistically.
Lee is a janitor in Boston and one day he receives a phone call saying his brother has died from heart failure. In his will, he wrote that Lee would be the legal guardian of his son, Patrick. But Lee doesn't know if he's responsible enough in this stage of his life to look after a 16 year old kid. He comes back to Manchester to look after Patrick and take care of funeral arrangements, upon his return, the demons of his past creep back up to haunt him.
One of the more depressing films of the year, the death of his brother is the least of his worries. Lonergan's script and direction are low-key and Lee's depressing past is told through flashbacks that correlate with the present. The tragedy of his past transforms Lee into a somber loner, not only withdrawn from family, but from life. The one thing that can be taken away from Manchester is how real it feels. Nothing in the film is played up for dramatic purposes, it simply has a depressing story to tell and it tells it.
Patrick, played by Lucas Hedges is a typical teenager, full of angst, depression, the desperate need for sex and aspirations to play in a band. His interactions with Lee are not so nice, but indeed are respectful. Their relationship is the centre of the film, it's neither strong nor weak, it's just a basic family bond. Michelle Williams has a small role as Lee's ex-wife, their relationship is almost non-existent and when you find out why, you can't help but feel for both of them in the situation. In one key scene, she clearly still loves him, but cannot be with him. They both hurt from this revelation but need to move on.
Manchester doesn't really have a wow factor. It's just a cold and depressing look at the realism of life.