The MoFo Top 100 Musicals Countdown

→ in
Tools    





Society researcher, last seen in Medici's Florence
#73. Everyone Says I Love You (1996) was my #5 for about one-third of its 58 pts.

Saw it in the theatre when it came out and numerous more times since then, even rewatched it again for the countdown to enjoy the moment. That's one of the movies which features ensemble of famous actors, arranged masterly by Woody Allen.
The music number in the jewelry house as well as the one along the river in night Paris are just great. A lot of jokes in-between...
Thanks everybody who supported this film!




-----

My Ballot

...
5. Everyone Says I Love You (1996) [#73]
6.
7. Monty Python's The Meaning of Life (1983) [#99]
8.
9. Amadeus (1984) [#97]
...
16. Rocketman (2019) [#91]
...
25. The Gypsy Camp Vanishes Into the Blue (1975) [one pointer]



-----
__________________
"Population don't imitate art, population imitate bad television." W.A.
"You can't depend on your eyes when your imagination is out of focus." M.T.



#73. Everyone Says I Love You (1996) was my #5 for about one-third of its 58 pts.

Saw it in the theatre when it came out and numerous more times since then, even rewatched it again for the countdown to enjoy the moment. That's one of the movies which features ensemble of famous actors, arranged masterly by Woody Allen.
The music number in the jewelry house as well as the one along the river in night Paris are just great. A lot of jokes in-between...
Thanks everybody who supported this film!




-----

My Ballot

...
5. Everyone Says I Love You (1996) [#73]
6.
7. Monty Python's The Meaning of Life (1983) [#99]
8.
9. Amadeus (1984) [#97]
...
16. Rocketman (2019) [#91]
...
25. The Gypsy Camp Vanishes Into the Blue (1975) [one pointer]



-----
Everyone Says I Love You is a cute movie and the 2 scenes you mentioned were my favorites too, but there’s no way it would have made my top 25



Society researcher, last seen in Medici's Florence
Everyone Says I Love You is a cute movie and the 2 scenes you mentioned were my favorites too, but there’s no way it would have made my top 25
Hm, I thought, you was one of the voters since few other users have ever mentioned it.



2022 Mofo Fantasy Football Champ
Seen 15/28 so far

3. Begin Again
4. Tick Tick Boom
14. West Side Story (2021)
17. 42nd Street
25. Brave Little Toaster (one pointer)



I forgot the opening line.
I'm having a good run for having seen movies, but not a good one for movies from my ballot :

74. Walk Hard : The Dewey Cox Story (2007) - Laughed a lot regarding this one, which I find to be a very funny comedy - skewering those musical biopics which we weren't done with yet by 2007, for we've seen plenty since. John C. Reilly is always a hoot, and rarely gets to grab hold of a lead role like this. "Let's Duet" has to be my favourite song - stuffed full of super double entendres. I didn't expect it to show up here though, and didn't vote for it.

73. Everyone Says I Love You (1996) - I like a lot of Woody Allen films, but I don't like this one. I wrote a long review on Letterboxd : " Whenever the collection isn't staring me in the face, I forget how many terrific films Woody Allen has made. Midnight in Paris, Annie Hall, Manhattan, Blue Jasmine, Hannah and Her Sisters, The Purple Rose of Cairo, Crimes and Misdemeanors, Irrational Man, Zelig, Love and Death, Deconstructing Harry, Radio Days, Sleeper, Husbands and Wives, Bananas, Everything You Wanted to Know About Sex, Stardust Memories, Wonder Wheel, Take the Money and Run, Interiors and more. It's a ridiculous film resume, and with his 50th film, Coup De Chance, out now you can obviously discern that he's made so many there are bound to be a few absolute clunkers that don't really work. Not every single one can be brilliant. Well, Everyone Says I Love You certainly isn't brilliant. It's a film made from Allen's comfort zone - his narrative familiarity with wealth, high society, and love combined awkwardly meshing in this musical that not only has Allen slurping lips with a much younger woman, but using information gleaned from her therapy sessions to trick her into bed with him. All's fair to Allen - he's not exactly a "Me Too" icon.

This film came out in-between Mighty Aphrodite and Deconstructing Harry, both of which I'm familiar with - but I was completely unaware of it's existence. It had passed me by. It has a stacked cast - Alan Alda, Woody himself, Drew Barrymore, Goldie Hawn, Edward Norton, Natalie Portman, Julia Roberts and Tim Roth are the A-listers, but they have talented backing. They all sing (unrehearsed) to varying degrees of success (Woody whispers - an adroit tactic, in the meantime poor tuneless Julia Roberts falls flat. At the other end of the spectrum, Woody had to demand Goldie Hawn "sing worse" to match the everyday quality of singing - she was too good a warbler), but the master filmmaker's taste in music is simply far too old fashioned and way too staid for me. At times this music choice works, but at others the needed contrast is missing. Dennis Potter turned this kind of musical into a high artform, while Woody is simply Woody. The one big tick for me was his developing love affair with European cities, and as such we see plenty of Paris and Venice - two wonderful locations for this kind of film. The big negative was Allen's penchant for his characters to be ostentatiously, filthy rich in the most vulgar fashion possible.

The story, as loose as it is, revolves around an extended family unit, and the various romantic relationships that both blossom and die among it's many members. As already noted, the one with Woody is the one that made me the most uncomfortable - but as an added bonus we have Tim Roth's Charles Ferry, the only non-wealthy character in the film. Just out of prison, and obviously hopelessly corrupt and corrupted, he forces himself upon Barrymore's Skylar which prompts her to fall in love with him and dump fiance Holden Spence (Edward Norton). Look, it's all lighthearted and silly - but often there's an undercurrent in Allen's films that raise little red flags. I'd have much preferred to see Skylar beat Ferry up - which would have been funny (little fancy, demur rich girl beating up hardened crim) and more appropriate. I know - it's all about love in it's many guises, but it's love through Woody Allen's eyes. I can't afford to jet around to Paris and Venice on a whim, and if I force myself on somebody they probably won't fall in love with me. Using information gathered by snooping on therapy sessions to seduce someone is creepy. I do, however, have a song in my heart - so when Allen shows us what this could have been with the song and dance at the end - by the Seine - it's a little too late, but still appreciated because that's magic."
That says enough.

Seen : 19/28
__________________
Remember - everything has an ending except hope, and sausages - they have two.

Latest Review : Double Down (2005)



Have seen neither of these but definitely know of them. So, obviously they didn't make it on my list. Oh well. There's always tomorrow. Tomorrow, tomorrow, I love you...never mind.

So far:
#1. On the Town #93 (list proper)
#6. Easter Parade #78 (list proper)
#10. Gigi #85 (list proper)
#12. Calamity Jane #84 (list proper)
#25. Neptune's Daughter (one-pointer).
__________________
"Miss Jean Louise, Mr. Arthur Radley."



The only films to make my ballot so far are The Band Wagon @ 15 and 42nd Street @ 16.

The only other films I've seen are Amadeus, which I love but never considered, Walk the Line, Purple Rain, Easter Parade and The Meaning of Life. Easter Parade is the only one I would have considered for my ballot but it just wasn't as good as my one pointer which is:

The Forbidden Zone and it wasn't a goofy pick. It's bat shit crazy and a lot of fun.



He's talking about yesterday's
I'd be okay just going ahead and saying, "I haven't seen either film," when talking about today's.
  • White Christmas - haven't seen despite how famous, well, the song from it is.
  • Purple Rain - haven't seen. I know someone who really likes this film, but I also don't really know how much Prince I listened to growing up (the number of songs Prince wrote on the other hand, I have more memories of), so I don't how much I'd end up liking this or not. Probably more appealing of a watch option than most generic musicals if they were presented to me though.
  • The Band Wagon - Another Minnelli, another one I haven't seen. Still haven't worked up the urge to see one. I'd assume I should start with Cabin in the Sky if I ever did. I had not heard of the title of this one before, but that isn't surprising.
  • Charlotte's Web - I saw this as a child and really adored it then. Didn't cross my mind when coming up with my list. No idea if it would have made it because I would have felt the need to rewatch it, and I... just kind of don't have that desire, despite having no real qualms with my memory of the movie. Though that would be more preferable to me than probably watching a number of the Disney musicals that will probably show up that I've never even seen once.
  • Easter Parade - Never heard of it.
  • Funny Girl - I don't know if I've seen any movie with Streisand in it.
  • 42nd Street - repeat my earlier comment about Busby Berkeley
  • The King and I - I watched this a number of times growing up and as a child I really liked it. I have no desire to revisit it as an adult. I get the vibe we should look forward to Little Orphan Annie showing up on this list (in terms of, "musical I remember watching a lot of as a little kid")
  • Walk Hard - Never seen, didn't know it was a musical. I guess it isn't surprising a parody of a musician bio-pic would be a musical. People say it's funny. I guess, I would watch this one. Reilly is usually funny (though I say that without having ever seen any of his movies with Will Ferrell)
  • Everyone Says I Love You - I saw this as a teen. I don't remember much about it and don't have much interest in revisiting it.





72
5lists58points
Yellow Submarine
Director

George Dunning, 1968

Starring

Paul Angelis, John Clive, Dick Emery, Geoffrey Hughes







71
4lists59points
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
Director

Stanley Donen, 1954

Starring

Jane Powell, Howard Keel, Jeff Richards, Russ Tamblyn





Trouble with a capital "T"
I'm not seeing the rep icon for both of the daily reveals. Yellow Submarine had the rep icon but Seven Brothers for Seven Brides. Anybody else not seeing the rep icon on the reveals? @Yoda



Two days in a row and I miss them both.

I had 42nd Street at #19. I watched it many years ago because I've always liked the title song, which alone is more than worth its place on this list, but there's some other decent songs (I prefer the lyrics to the music or singing for most of them) and there's the Busby choreography, if you like that kind of thing. It's very pretty, inventive and quite mesmerising if nothing else. But I really do love that title song.

Drew Barrymore made a musical? Of course I have it on my list. It's my #2. I felt I couldn't give it top spot because there's not a song on there I love (and this is a musicals list so I tried to give some credence to that) so second it had to be. Actually, Drew doesn't sing in the film (as she 'convinced' Allen her voice was too awful, even for someone not able to sing. But I suspect he did hear her and, maybe, agreed?) but, that doesn't matter because she's there and she's glorious and I really like the film too. It really is what it says it is, a Woody Allen musical, so if you don't care for either of those parts I'd be surprised if there's anything her for you and it's very much in the classic 30's/50's Hollywood musical style. But I like Allen and it's got Drew, so I saw this at the earliest opportunity (I think it was '97 by the time it was released over here?) and I knew it'd be first or second on my list from the moment it was possible this countdown would happen.

I don't see the rep button for Seven Brides and it's not there for Walk Hard either.
__________________
5-time MoFo Award winner.



Thursday Next's Avatar
I never could get the hang of Thursdays.
The 5-point gap between yesterday's The King and I and today's Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story is the biggest one so far. So far, we've had 8 ties, but as we get down the list, this separation will keep growing.
You would think so, but there are ties all the way down! There's a 4-way tie in the 60s, a 3-way tie in the 30s, a tie in the 20s and three movies in the top 20 separated only by one point. There are some interesting point jumps, too, which I can't say anything more about just yet.



Thursday Next's Avatar
I never could get the hang of Thursdays.
I'm not seeing the rep icon for both of the daily reveals. Yellow Submarine had the rep icon but Seven Brothers for Seven Brides. Anybody else not seeing the rep icon on the reveals? @Yoda
I think it's just because the title is so long! I can't see the time stamp on this or Walk Hard either.

Reply to Topic