Let me start by saying that Bruce Wayne is the only Batman, ever to me. This whole new Dick Grayson and Damian thing just isn’t working out. Bruce Wayne, I love how he also had to manage a busy playboy life beyond the Bat lifestyle, Dick doesn’t have that responsibility. That’s why I’m not really reading the bat books now except for Batman Confidential.
This was an okay arc. I loved how the Bat Wing was turned against him. Plus, seeing Alfred in action for one page was fun. I must say though, they made this almost too advanced technology wise. I’m willing to accept the Bat Wing flying around the city, undetected by police when it goes into Wayne’s place, and how Batman gets bats to follow him to evade radar. There are a couple of things that just went to “out there” like, to not spoil it, it’s that Batman gets hurt but doesn’t say “OW” or something along those lines. That’s what I liked about Year One. When Wayne got hurt, he said “OW” and such. Plus, the battle at the end, just makes him seem to much like Superman.
Also, the art wasn’t very good. His facial expressions weren’t very good and a lot of the times the character designs were to small.
Rating: 2.5/5 If you like Superman stories, you’ll like this.
This is the best Confidential story arc. I’ll say that now and get that out of the way. I love stories with villains, become supervillians. One of the books I love called “Invincible” got this right. We meet the man BEFORE he put on the mask or deformation took place. This was Batman’s first encounter with Joker (in this book,) and his transformation took a big part in the story. I love when books do that.
Also, giving the Joker a definitive origin (in this book anyway,) was a BIG risk. I mean sure this story will amount to nothing in the other books, since it’s not canon because it takes place in the past and changes a lot, but it could still tick a lot of fans off. It really didn’t make me feel for The Joker as much as something, say The Killing Joke, but this origin was still very good.
Plus, Michael played up the whole Bruce Wayne's social life struggles, angle of the story, and we show just how far he'll go to catch criminals.
The only bad thing, again was the art. The facial expressions again were off again and there were a lot of stray black lines annoyed me and I'm not sure why they were there.
Grade: 3.7/5 Too good to say 3.5 but not good enough to give it the full 4/5
Wrath Child
Issue Numbers: 13-16
Writer: Antony J L Bedard - 'Tony'
Penciller: Ralph Morales - 'Rags'
The problem with this comic is that it’s already been told. I’ve already seen people dress up as a hero and do bad things. That story was in The Punisher, and ya know what, they did it better. Still, this was kind of a fun ride. Predictable, but fun. I must note though that Tony does do something weird, by having this book go about 20 years ahead from the last arc.
I did like Ralph Morales' art though. I've always been a fan of the really straight lined, more realistic looking, like Dale Eaglesham from JSA.
P.S. I still think Nightwing looks funny.
Rating: 3/5 Just okay, I wouldn’t go out of my way to buy it but if you like Batman you won’t be disappointed.
Do you guys know the first step of making a great hero or villain? At least in the case for me, it’s the origin, and Batgirl’s origin isn’t to good. There’s no real hook to it, it's just "oh I can't become a cop but want to beat up criminals, I know, I'll become a bat!" Bruce, hell even Dick have better reasons to do what they do than that.
This was a real change of pace though, no one died, there were little fights but nothing where people get freakin’ insinigrated, or a madmen running around murdering a lot of people, or robot armies killing militaries, it was about getting back a notebook. It was nice for a little “phew” from heavy handed stories.
The two things really wrong with it, was that he wrote Batman as a complete and total ******* who didn’t care about anyone else really besides himself. Plus, Batgirl’s a freaking brat who could have messed up bad, just out of her “curiosity”.
I did like the very clean art again. I also liked that outside of the nudist club it wasn't to sexualized.
Rating: 2.5/5
Do You Understand These Rights?
Issue Numbers: 22-25,
Writer: Andrew Kreisberg
Penciller: Scott McDaniel
The problem with this book, is also what drove me to this book, that problem being continuity. Now, I can’t STAND when one title goes to another title and you have to read like three titles to keep going with a story of one of your favorite characters (Cough All those damn Batman books, cough) but when you’re changing the past you set up in the SAME FREAKIN’ BOOK NOT EVEN A YEAR BEFOREHAND, I get a little bugged. Now Lovers & Madmen, The Joker’s and Batman’s first encounter in BC was a great origin for him and I personally loved it. Andrew Kreisberg changed it though! It was just lazy as in “Oh f**k what happened before, I’m changing it.
Another thing Kreisberg did wrong was he just made it unbelievable. I’m all willing to suspend belief buy a lot of his kills at the end have about 0 chance of ever happening and even a man like The Joker couldn’t believably plan for it.
Continuity and believability aside, Kreisberg does have a very nice handle on the character of The Joker as a deranged psycho. And, I really like how one of the cops go insane (trying to avoid spoilers) it was a nice little what if The Killing Joke’s plan had worked on Gordon and I enjoyed it, and it does come up again in another arc.
McDaniel’s art is okay. Nothing wowed me like say Brian Bolland (WOW I gotta quit mentioning The Killing Joke) it was way to blocky for my tastes. Also, I don’t know why the colorist I.L.L. did all the outside shots with a red tint to them? It didn’t make a lick of sense.
Rating: 2.3/5 Too good to say 2 and not good enough to say 2.5.
A New Dawn
Issue Numbers: 26–28
Writer(s): Nunzio DeFilippis & Christina Weir
Penciller: Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez
I loved this arc, I’m pretty sure this beats out every other arc in BC art-wise at least. Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez (that’s a mouthful) is a true talent, and even though I haven’t seen anything besides this, I’ll defiantly be seeking out more.
The writing was pretty good I loved the take on the Riddler and actually making him a good villain. I’ve never really been a fan before this but as you all probably know by now, I’m a fan of heroes (or at least in this case help solve a case) who have done kind of bad stuff (steal a lot of stuff in this case.) I liked how he didn’t care at all about the victim and such, he just hated the guy for stealing his M.O.
Although, I didn’t entirely get the whole “robbery” aspect of it, I mean it didn’t really amount to much. Oh well the end hints at another arc and I’d welcome it if the same team returned.
Rating: 4/5
Good Cop… …Bad Cop
Issue Numbers: 29-30
Writer: Andrew Kreisberg
Penciller: Scott McDaniel
The sequel to Do You Understand These Rights, is, surprisingly better. I just view this as a Killing Joke what if, like what if Joker’s plan had driven Gordon crazy? It’s nice to just see that played out, kind of like The Dark Knight did. Although, I did find the suicidal aspect of it a bit to similar to The Joker’s Lovers and Madmen schemes, oh well, it’s still nice to see Batman fight new guys, and interesting themes develop.
The art again was pretty blocky but word must go out about the beautiful page spreads he did. Maybe if McDaniel just had more room to work, and a new colorist, his art would be a lot better.
Rating: 3.5/5 Look it’s literally 2 issues long, it’s not a long read and you could just jump on here. It’s worth the about $8.