0
A while back I tried to watch the original The Longest Yard (1974) around the same time I viewed Sandler's version (2005).
I have to admit, this analysis may not be entirely fair as I never viewed Sandler's version in its entirety (it was on commercial TV which also means it was highly edited).
While what I saw of the two movies convinced me they were virtually the same story with even many of the same lines and jokes (which led me to question why re-make the original at all?), I was also pleased to see Burt Reynolds playing Nate Scarborough (although, here too, I wonder what Burt was thinking? Just trying to make an extra buck in his old age by capitalizing on one of his classics? Not that I blame him, but I felt it somehow lowered the respect to the memory of the original).
What stood out to me though, (and why I'm posting this) was how the same jokes were played off in the two different eras:
In 1974, the humor felt natural, it had irony, it didn't hit you over the head or require explanation or extra exposition. The difference I saw with Sandler, making the exact same jokes, is it felt like they were all followed with some sort of explanation to make sure the audience got it (hitting them over the head as it were).
And I kind of see that aspect in most of Sandler's comedies. It's like his writers consider current generations too inept to interpret irony, understatement or juxtaposition within comedy and thus it must all be explained to them via either accompanying visual gags or verbal explanations. I think this may be one reason Sandler has so many detractors when it comes to his comedies.
It reminds of humor in the cringe-worthy Disney Channel children's programs where it's so forced, overly obvious, and requires explanation as the producers don't seem to regard their child-target-audiences as having any natural intuition for comedy at all.
I wish I had some specific examples to demonstrate what I mean, but too much time has gone by and most of the specifics from The Longest Yard remake have faded from my memory, but I get the feeling that those old enough to have seen the original back in the 70's and who have seen the remake will know what I mean.